Key Takeaways
- Seeking dual experience across provider and payer sectors equips leaders with the fluency needed to dismantle silos and drive integrated solutions.
- Non-clinician leaders build physician trust by centering strategies on patient care continuity and involving clinicians early in change initiatives.
- Prioritize regular, courageous dialogue and relationship building during stable times to prevent long-term organizational dysfunction.
- Senior executives should engage directly with frontline staff through job shadowing and informal touchpoints to maintain strategic perspective and operational grounding.
- Secure buy-in for soft investments by directly linking customer experience initiatives to enterprise-level financial and operational KPIs.
Introduction: Why Provider-Payer Collaboration Defines Healthcare Leadership in 2025
Healthcare executives are navigating a landscape shaped by consolidation, physician shortages, value-based care, and relentless disruption. Amidst this, one timeless imperative stands out: closing the gap between providers and payers for improved patient outcomes and organizational performance. The American Journal of Healthcare Strategy sat down with Kenyokee Crowell, MBA, CEO & Founder at Prodigy Advisors LLC and former SVP at major Pittsburgh health systems, to uncover how her experience leading both provider and payer teams informs a playbook for today’s leaders.
Why does this matter now? The lack of alignment between hospitals and insurers is cited by the American Hospital Association as a key barrier to value-based transformation, while a 2023 McKinsey report found that organizations with integrated leadership across the care continuum outperform peers on cost and quality. In this episode, Crowell reveals actionable approaches for breaking silos, earning physician trust as a non-clinician, and building resilient teams—lessons urgent for today’s SVPs, directors, and rising administrative fellows.
What Makes Dual-Side Healthcare Leadership So Valuable?
Having experience on both the provider and payer sides uniquely positions healthcare leaders to break down silos and drive integrated solutions. Crowell’s career exemplifies this dual fluency.
“Having the opportunity to work and learn both sides... that’s probably one of the most beneficial things that I’ve done in my career... it really gave me deeper insights and more robust insights into the problem solving, finding common ground, and really aligning different parties around common goals.”
Key benefits of cross-sector experience include:
-
Broader fluency in healthcare “language” and culture.
-
Ability to mediate misunderstandings and build common goals.
-
Greater credibility and adaptability in executive roles.
-
Enhanced capability to lead mergers, acquisitions, and physician integration.
For executives, intentionally seeking experience or partnerships across both domains is increasingly not just a differentiator, but a necessity.
How Do You Align Physicians Without Being a Clinician?
Non-clinician leaders can win physician trust and drive integration by centering patient care, actively listening, and creating true partnership. Crowell outlines the specific strategies she used leading physician integration at Cleveland Clinic and Highmark.
“Doctors want to be able to do what they do best, which is caring for patients... Typically, when I’ve seen a mismatch or conflict, it goes back to that principle—maybe we as non-clinical leaders are making that charge to care for patients more challenging.”
Practical steps for physician integration:
-
Prioritize continuity of care and partnership: The ultimate goal is “greater continuity of care for the patients that you are serving, which should improve outcomes and quality of care.”
-
Bring physicians into change conversations early: “We should bring them to the table and we should engage them in a meaningful way... Have we created a compelling value proposition and actually helped them understand how what we are trying to accomplish is actually a mutually beneficial thing?”
-
Accept conflict as a sign of honest engagement: “If everybody that you work with... is like ‘oh that’s fantastic, that’s great’—chances are you aren’t challenging the system enough or you’re not being honest with them about what the change and the impacts really are.”
Bottom line: For non-clinical leaders, credibility comes not from clinical credentials, but from how rigorously you center the patient and respect the physician’s mission.
Why Is Courageous Dialogue Crucial for Healthcare Leaders?
Avoidance of hard conversations breeds long-term dysfunction; courageous, regular engagement is a leadership imperative. Many organizations fail not from disagreement but from a lack of direct, honest dialogue.
“We have to do a better job at having difficult conversations in the right way and engaging in that courageous dialogue... If you’re only engaging with providers when there’s a problem, you can’t expect that they’re going to always receive that well.”
Best practices to foster courageous dialogue:
-
Build political capital before crisis—invest in relationships when things are calm.
-
Use regular touchpoints, not just crisis meetings, to engage clinicians.
-
Cultivate professional, collegial tone, even during conflict.
-
Don’t retreat into remote silos; “if you’re not willing to roll up your sleeves and get in it, it’s easier in the short term but going to cause huge problems in the long term.”
This aligns with research from the Harvard Business Review showing that organizations with a culture of open dialogue outperform peers on change management and innovation.
How Can Healthcare Leaders Build Customer-Centric Cultures, Even from the Payer Side?
Customer experience is not just for hospitals; payers and back-office functions also shape the patient journey. Crowell dispels the myth that payers are simply “gatekeepers,” explaining how all teams can develop customer obsession.
“Regardless of that, at the end of the line there is a patient or sometimes a customer that we are trying to impact... Insurance plans are not there to stop people from getting care; they are there to help facilitate people getting care and make sure it’s the appropriate care for the condition and it’s evidence-based.”
To build a customer-centric culture at all levels:
-
Directly connect every function—even coding, finance, or insurance—to its impact on patients.
-
Regularly shadow front-line teams to understand real-world challenges.
-
Advocate internally for patient-centric process improvements, not just cost containment.
-
Reinforce the “Amazon principle” of customer obsession: “Institutions that focus on customer experience as a science... all of their staff members having that seem to succeed.”
Leaders who operationalize customer-centricity—especially on the payer side—position their organizations for stronger partnerships and improved patient loyalty.
What Are the Top Three Tactics for Senior Leaders to Stay Connected with Their Teams?
Senior executives must deliberately avoid losing touch with the daily realities of their teams. Crowell shares three practical tactics:
-
Job Shadowing: “Whenever I’ve gone to a new job, I do job shadowing... sitting for 30 minutes and understanding what that role is, kind of interviewing that employee.”
-
Town Halls: “Quarterly meetings where I’m talking about my vision for the strategy of the organization, how we’re impacting the larger organization, and highlighting the good work that’s going on.”
-
Coffee Chats: “Small groups—most of these are done virtually—open dialogue, they can ask me anything they want, share concerns, very informal setting to connect with the people you are leading.”
Direct answer: These methods not only build morale but also inform executive decisions, as executives gain an unfiltered view of strengths and pain points on the ground.
“As a senior leader, the worst mistake you can make... is to get too far away from understanding and appreciating the work that is happening on a daily basis to drive the organization forward.”
This is corroborated by Gallup research showing that employees with regular executive interaction report higher engagement and retention.
How Can Executives Sell “Soft” Investments Like Customer Experience to Finance-Focused Senior Leadership?
Convincing skeptical CFOs and boards to invest in customer experience requires storytelling, strategic alignment, and understanding how work gets done.
“Every organization is a little bit different and you have to understand how work gets done in an organization... How do the new strategies you are trying to employ align with the organizational goals? That’s the story you need to tell.”
Step-by-step for selling “soft” initiatives:
-
Map out how the investment ties to enterprise-level priorities.
-
Identify and cultivate key stakeholders before formal presentations.
-
Develop narratives linking customer experience to financial and operational KPIs.
-
Collect frontline anecdotes and data from your engagement tactics (shadowing, coffee chats, etc.) to strengthen your case.
This mirrors playbooks recommended by both the Institute for Healthcare Improvement and leading consulting firms: successful change is both top-down (strategy) and bottom-up (storytelling).
How Do You Sustain Focus and Resilience Through Seismic Industry Change?
Adaptability and focus on controllable actions are crucial for healthcare leaders managing turbulence—from COVID to political upheaval.
“You have to be adaptable... You cannot control [external factors] but what you can control is your reaction... and the path you take to achieve your goal.”
Crowell’s practical advice:
-
Focus on “the Triumph of the human spirit”—recognize that “the bigger the problem, people tend to come together.”
-
Keep your “eye on the prize” while remaining flexible on tactics.
-
Accept that you can’t predict or control external dynamics, but you can control your response and leadership choices.
Direct answer: Leaders who stay adaptable and intentionally build teams for resilience not only weather change—they set the tone for organizational stability and innovation.
Takeaway: Leadership Is Bridging, Listening, and Acting for the Patient
The U.S. healthcare system’s complexity is both its greatest challenge and its richest opportunity. The leaders who bridge provider and payer, clinical and non-clinical, and strategy and execution are those who will drive real transformation.
As Kenyokee Crowell, MBA, CEO & Founder at Prodigy Advisors LLC, models: the best executives never move too far from the front lines, always keep the patient at the center, and continually adapt to what the moment demands. Whether you’re leading a team of ten or ten thousand, commit to courageous dialogue, relentless customer focus, and authentic partnership with clinicians—and you’ll build an organization that thrives through disruption.
<p>hello everyone this is Cole from the American Journal of healthc care strategy I'm joined by a very special guest kenoki kenoki please introduce yourself hi good afternoon thanks for having me Cole um my name is kenoi croll and I am a senior Healthcare leader um I have sign significant experience working on both the provider and payer side uh based in the Pittsburgh area um for the last uh seven years of my career I spent at a very large Healthcare organization uh in the Pittsburgh area and since last uh summer I uh took an intentional intermission from my career uh to pursue some personal interests and travel extensively which has been really great and I'm also staying uh you know professionally active and I um serve as an executive leadership coach and have had the opportunity and privilege to coach uh some folks and um also the opportunity to do a little bit of Consulting on customer engagement and customer uh collaboration during this little bit of an intermission that I'm taking so thanks for having me [Music] today so happy to have you you've been in this field for it looks like 24 25 years right yes yes yes um a long time time um and kind of getting to the point where sometimes you don't want to put all the years of experience you have in an industry because it's been uh many many years but it's been um amazing and I've had the opportunity over those years to work in just about every area of healthc care um which has been fantastic and um it's a industry I'm passionate about um and it's a very customer Centric in uh industry which I'm also passionate about so it's been an amazing amazing career so far looking at kind of your LinkedIn resume here you worked in kind of operations at Cleveland Clinic um and then you did physician integration clinical access at High Mark uh Clinical Services and then a clinical organization and so you you've gotten both leadership of teams at Cleveland Clinic like you mentioned on the the healthc care side and then at High Mark on the insurance side of things what benefit did it give you to know both the hospital you know Health provider end and the insurance side of things that's a great question and I will tell you um having the opportunity to work and learn both sides I would say that's probably one of the most beneficial uh things that I've done in my career and I think for so many of us we work in one lane or the other and as you know uh working in healthc care yourself um there are a lot of disconnects sometimes that can exist between those two sides um in terms of how we understand each other the language that we speak um which is often different um and how we collaborate and problem solve um so for me I think to be able to work in that lane as well and learn that and impact meaningful work um it really just expanded my language um and my fluency in healthc care as an industry and it really gave me deeper insights and more robust insights into the problem solving finding common ground um and really aligning uh different parties around common goals so for me it was an excellent choice to take that leap um and really have learned a lot of things that I think will carry me um uh well through the rest of my career I agree I agree I I mean looking at at the resume and already talking with you briefly it's you know you can tell that you're you're knowledgeable about kind of the 360 degrees of healthare one of the areas that I'm particularly interested in right now with all these mergers and Acquisitions physician shortages is the four years that you spent as a kind of doing physician integration at Cleveland Clinic what were your outcomes there for that what are some of the challenges you faced and how did you overcome them sure sure so without kind of sharing anything confidential on the organizational strategy I would say that um aligning Physicians I think um just as an industry industry practice is a is an important um thing to do and I think um when you're looking at doing that whether you are a healthc care organization that is acquiring facilities meaning hospitals or clinics or cancer centers or acquiring practices or just looking at new and unique ways to align um uh providers with your organizations I think the outcomes that you are going to desire is number one you want to be able to have greater continuity of care for the patients that you are serving um which should improve outcomes and quality of of care um you also want to enhance the partnership levels that you have with those providers and when I say partnership I don't necessarily mean signing a contract saying you will do this for me but really kind of being and living in the same space together um and that can have impacts on um making sure patients get the care that they need when they need it Greater collaboration between referring providers greater collaboration and cooperation when it comes to things like uh throughput and making sure patients are discharged timely um and have the resources that they need it just kind of elevates the communication game um is in a lot of different ways and it can improve outcomes for patients I I really feel strongly about that and I I agree and here's one of the problems that I see though is that you know we we have physician leaders who still practice they go in and they work with their fellow Physicians but you're not a physician yourself neither am I how can we be involved with them as non-physicians how could we get that you said that shared space that is um that's an excellent question and it's I think a million-dollar question and um I will say my entire career I've worked with f Physicians and clinicians and have an extraordinary amount of respect uh for the skill and commitment that they have and I think for me um I really once I truly understood in a very robust way that um doctors want to be able to do what they do best which is caring for patients and typically in my career when I've seen that you've got a mismatch of understandings or some conflict with the provider that you're trying to collaborate or work with it usually goes back down to that principle and the fact that maybe we as non-clinical leaders and administrators in health care we may be doing something that is interrupting or making uh that charge to care for patients more more challenging or more difficult or um we are trying to move fast and Implement change but we haven't done a great job at making sure one we have all the right voices at the table in terms of if we're creating new things or changing things and moving cheese for lack of a better term that's going to affect um how provider see and care for patients we should bring them to the table and we should ask them their opinion and we should engage them in a meaningful way in that and then I think also too have we as administrative leaders and non-clinical leaders have we created a compelling value proposition and actually help them understand how what we are trying to accomplish is actually a mutually beneficial thing um so I think we have to um as non-clinical Leaders we have got to meet our clinical colleagues where they're at and understand um what they are trying to accomplish and at the end of the day in healthc care we are all here to serve the patient period I don't care what role you have we are all here to serve the patient improve the health of the population and we've got to understand and respect that providers um and and any clinician for that matter they are the closest to that um and we need to respect that we need to try to understand it and we need to try to collaborate in a more effective way and um I feel in my career I've been able to successfully do that um that doesn't mean that I have not had providers and Physicians during my career that were not happy with me or that I was dealing with conflict and that's expected um because I think honestly if you go through your career as a administrative leader working with clinical leaders and everybody that you work with that's a clinical person is like oh that's fantastic that's great chances are you aren't challenging the system enough and bringing them to the table as partners or you're not being honest with them about what the change and the impacts really are which is not good either because we know you know I I like to be involved with a few physician groups and we know even amongst Physicians there is disagreement there is um struggle to try to push us in a better Direction right and that's something that even goes on in the groups do you think that maybe part of the problem isn't so much of that disagreement or that confrontation as you said but more so the avoidance that sometimes administrators can take out of fear right if we don't hear the problems if we don't talk to them if I could hide in my office or or work remote Etc then I don't have to deal with it um I I think part of it is um I think we in general Ro in the healthcare industry and we're probably not the only industry we have to do a better job at having difficult conversations in the right way and engaging in that courageous dialogue and I think that you're right if you're working remotely and um you're not willing to roll up your sleeves and get in it um it's easier in the short term but as boys are going to cause huge problems in the long term so I think um and I think that's something we have to work at too of course that sort of dialogue and engaging in that way um which can sometimes be tense but should always be professional and collegial um that that doesn't come as a natural ability to a lot of people um or um they don't have enough political Capital built up with that audience where they can navigate that successfully and I think that's when it goes back to if you're only engaging with the providers that you're working with when there's a problem or there's a change um you can't expect that they're going to always receive that well and I think um as you know it's all about building relationships with all those stakeholders and kind of investing in that throughout the process um which isn't going to make the conflicts and any issues ues or any disagreements on what direction to go and strategically go away but it's going to arm both parties to actually come to the table and have that dialogue and I think we got away from that a little bit I think in covid um because everybody kind of went to their own corners and did their own things um but I think whether you're still in a fully virtual environment a hybrid environment or an in-person environment you can still kind of cultivate those connections in a meaningful way but you have to make the effort in order to do that right no 100% I I love that and then and I I mean I've seen the rewards of doing that with a lot of my leaders who take tremendous time to connect with with Physicians or clinicians or just other members of their organization one of the struggles I want to ask you about is is at High Mark right you're transitioning to the insurance more towards the insurance realm do you feel like it requires even more effort because now you're one step further removed from the actual patient encounter compared to where you were at Cleveland Clinic um so for me and I will say this has been true throughout my career I would say um I've never been a clinical person which we've talked about before um but I think for me which what keeps me in healthc care is that whatever role I've had I want to understand what that customer experience is that that my team is impacting um in understanding that in a really meaningful way so I'll give you an an example so I have had um jobs throughout my career where I'm working in a clinical setting you're working in a hospital in a physician practice Etc I've also worked in revenue cycle or in coding or in Acquisitions as we talked about or on the insurance side but regardless of that at the end of the line there is a there is a patient or uh sometimes a customer that we are trying to impact and I think just to take insurance as an example um you are there for the customer you are there for whatever function you're doing you're trying to facilitate timely care for that individual your organization might not be delivering that care or employing the people that delivers that care but you are trying to facilitate it and you are also trying to advocate for that patient and that individual to make sure they're getting the appropriate care um and I think so many times um and this is something I don't I truly understood until I hit more exposure to that insurance side um in insurance plans regardless of where they are in the country they are not there to stop people from getting care they are there to help facilitate people getting care and they're there to make sure it's the appropriate care for the condition and it's evidence-based and all those sorts of things um so at the end of the day wherever you are in any Healthcare organization whether you you sit in the finance department you sit in operations you sit in a care delivery facility you are there to serve a function that in some way will impact that end customer which is your patient this episode of the strategy of Health was sponsored by modality Global advisors modality Global advisors optimizes Hospital Revenue enhances patient experience and delivers proven results visit modality Global advisors.com to learn more very well put and I think that what Amazon calls it right is this customer Obsession and that's what made Amazon better than the other retails um that they were competing against and I think that you see that in healthcare as well right uh you know institutions that focus on customer experience as a science and and put so much effort into all of their staff members having that seem to succeed um one of the things though is that at you're at the SVP level right now you're you were um that's higher up you're managing more and more people underneath you you you're now managing managers that manage people that that's challenging because you're you're now it's not just you making you know these decisions it's other people making more and more decisions it's a Cascade right how did you build these teams up the individuals who were underneath you so that they also had this customer Obsession this customer involvement that you did um it's it's all about um as the leader of that team whether that team you know as an SVP is 10 people or 10,000 people or something in between um it's about aligning your team around the priorities and what's important to the organization overall and what is our role within that department and within that team in order to support that that is entirely critical and I think um you have to outline those priorities um and a lot of time those priorities are coming from above Enterprise or organizational priorities but sometimes they're coming from within from the conversations you have with your team so I think aligning people around that priorities generating an enthusiasm um and I think as a senior executive it's critically important and this is something I've lived by and it's my advice for anyone is don't move too far away from all the great work that's happening in the ranks of the organization and I will tell you you know being a senior executive and having hundreds or a thousand people um indirectly in your organization clearly you're not going to be having conversations with all thousand or all 500 on a regular basis if you are you're probably not doing the job and moving the big boulders and and and motivating the team to success the way you need to but what you can do is create forums and opportunities to ensure that you're staying connected to that so some tactics that I've used is I have done whenever I've gone to a new job I do job shadowing so who are what are the Frontline roles in my organization and sitting for 30 minutes and understanding what that role is kind of interviewing that employee and I'm not doing hundreds of these but I'm doing you know a dozen or so whatever the roles are in the organization um you can also employ I did town halls with my team so quarterly meetings where I'm talking about my vision for the strategy of the...
The weekly briefing for healthcare strategists
Join 13,000+ executives getting actionable insights on strategy, AI, and innovation.
Share Your Expertise
Want to reach healthcare executives and decision-makers? Join industry leaders like HealthMap Solutions on our podcast.
Become a Guest